60 research outputs found
Sets of Priors Reflecting Prior-Data Conflict and Agreement
In Bayesian statistics, the choice of prior distribution is often debatable,
especially if prior knowledge is limited or data are scarce. In imprecise
probability, sets of priors are used to accurately model and reflect prior
knowledge. This has the advantage that prior-data conflict sensitivity can be
modelled: Ranges of posterior inferences should be larger when prior and data
are in conflict. We propose a new method for generating prior sets which, in
addition to prior-data conflict sensitivity, allows to reflect strong
prior-data agreement by decreased posterior imprecision.Comment: 12 pages, 6 figures, In: Paulo Joao Carvalho et al. (eds.), IPMU
2016: Proceedings of the 16th International Conference on Information
Processing and Management of Uncertainty in Knowledge-Based Systems,
Eindhoven, The Netherland
Bayes linear analysis of imprecision in computer models, with application to understanding galaxy formation.
Imprecision arises naturally in the context of computer models and their relation to reality. An imprecise treatment of general computer models is presented, illustrated with an analysis of a complex galaxy formation simulation known as Galform. The analysis involves several different types of uncertainty, one of which (the Model Discrepancy) comes directly from expert elicitation regarding the deficiencies of the model. The Model Discrepancy is therefore treated within an Imprecise framework to reflect more accurately the beliefs of the expert concerning the discrepancy between the model and reality. Due to the conceptual complexity and computationally intensive nature of such a Bayesian imprecise uncertainty analysis, Bayes Linear Methodology is employed which requires consideration of only expectations and variances of all uncertain quantities. Therefore incorporating an Imprecise treatment within a Bayes Linear analysis is shown to be relatively straightforward. The impact of an imprecise assessment on the input space of the model is determined through the use of an Implausibility measure
Bayes Linear Analysis of Imprecision in Computer Models, with Application to Understanding Galaxy Formation
Imprecision arises naturally in the context of computer models and their relation to reality. An imprecise treatment of general computer models is presented, illustrated with an analysis of a complex galaxy formation simulation known as Galform. The analysis involves several different types of uncertainty, one of which (the Model Discrepancy) comes directly from expert elicitation regarding the deficiencies of the model. The Model Discrepancy is therefore treated within an Imprecise framework to reflect more accurately the beliefs of the expert concerning the discrepancy between the model and reality. Due to the conceptual complexity and computationally intensive nature of such a Bayesian imprecise uncertainty analysis, Bayes Linear Methodology is employed which requires consideration of only expectations and variances of all uncertain quantities. Therefore incorporating an Imprecise treatment within a Bayes Linear analysis is shown to be relatively straightforward. The impact of an imprecise assessment on the input space of the model is determined through the use of an Implausibility measure
Uncertainty quantification in lasso-type regularization problems
Regularization techniques, which sit at the interface of statistical modeling and machine learning, are often used in the engineering or other applied sciences to tackle high dimensional regression (type) problems. While a number of regularization methods are commonly used, the 'Least Absolute Shrinkage and Selection Operator' or simply LASSO is popular because of its efficient variable selection property. This property of the LASSO helps to deal with problems where the number of predictors is larger than the total number of observations, as it shrinks the coefficients of non-important parameters to zero. In this chapter, both frequentist and Bayesian approaches for the LASSO are discussed, with particular attention to the problem of uncertainty quantification of regression parameters. For the frequentist approach, we discuss a refit technique as well as the classical bootstrap method, and for the Bayesian method, we make use of the equivalent LASSO formulation using a Laplace prior on the model parameters
Bayes linear kinematics in the analysis of failure rates and failure time distributions
Collections of related Poisson or binomial counts arise, for example, from a number of different failures in similar machines or neighbouring time periods. A conventional Bayesian analysis requires a rather indirect prior specification and intensive numerical methods for posterior evaluations. An alternative approach using Bayes linear kinematics in which simple conjugate specifications for individual counts are linked through a Bayes linear belief structure is presented. Intensive numerical methods are not required. The use of transformations of the binomial and Poisson parameters is proposed. The approach is illustrated in two examples, one involving a Poisson count of failures, the other involving a binomial count in an analysis of failure times
Evaluation of elicitation methods to quantify Bayes linear models
The Bayes linear methodology allows decision makers to express their subjective beliefs and adjust these beliefs as observations are made. It is similar in spirit to probabilistic Bayesian approaches, but differs as it uses expectation as its primitive. While substantial work has been carried out in Bayes linear analysis, both in terms of theory development and application, there is little published material on the elicitation of structured expert judgement to quantify models. This paper investigates different methods that could be used by analysts when creating an elicitation process. The theoretical underpinnings of the elicitation methods developed are explored and an evaluation of their use is presented. This work was motivated by, and is a precursor to, an industrial application of Bayes linear modelling of the reliability of defence systems. An illustrative example demonstrates how the methods can be used in practice
- …